Just another WordPress weblog

Archive for March, 2012

Council Backflip

The East Gippsland Shire Council executive has recommended to Councillors that Council continue with its Coastal Management Act application to construct the Option 3b breakwater and beach road. The Councillors will vote on this recommendation on 3 April 2012. Please see our Media Release, and the agenda item here.

The council proposal references the report by the Department of Transport on the public submission period on the designs. Please see the DoT report here.

The SBPC submission to the review on Hyder options is here.

If you would like to send a message to East Gippsland Shire Councillors, please copy their direct email addresses from below, or contact phone numbers are available here.

cr.ellis@egipps.vic.gov.au; cr.pelz@egipps.vic.gov.au; cr.anderson@egipps.vic.gov.au; cr.buckley@egipps.vic.gov.au; cr.freshwater@egipps.vic.gov.au; cr.gamble@egipps.vic.gov.au; cr.urie@egipps.vic.gov.au; cr.rowe@egipps.vic.gov.au; cr.neal@egipps.vic.gov.au


Submissions Closed On Latest Options

The Campaign would like to thank the many supporters who made submissions over the very short period allotted for us to review the complex engineering plans exhibited by the Department of Transport project team. The Department is now analysing the submissions, and will present the results to East Gippsland Shire Council. Council is believed to be voting on this issue at its 3 April 2012 meeting – whether to shelve the Option 3b breakwater/beach road and commit to an upgrade of the current boat ramp site, or continue down its path of supporting Option 3b.

If you would like a copy of our submission, please contact us on coordinator@savebastionpoint.org. We will be in contact with supporters when we know more about the process surrounding the vote at Council – which will be at least the fourth time Council votes on this project.


Submission Deadline 11 March 2012

The deadline on the 11 March is fast approaching for submissions on the Hyder Proposal. Please get your feedback in now – either by emailing to

bastionpoint@transport.vic.gov.au or filling in the attached feedback form and faxing, mailing or attaching pdf to email address.

Melbourne consultation on Hyder designs

The Melbourne consultation session was held on 7 March with about 50 people attending the session. Question themes that came from participants included:

> The short time period for preparation of submissions.
> The observation that visual amenity was given an overall weighting of 3% in the analyses.
> No assessment or consideration in analyses on the impacts on surfing.
> The fact that the analysis had only been run  with the smaller H2 breakwater and not the larger one which was recommended, which has led to confusion as to its final scoring in the analysis.
> Concern with the perception that we are only being offered a ‘choice’ between the large breakwater options H2 and Option 3b.
> Seemingly arbitrary scorings in the analyses that pushed the lower impact Alternative Option down in rankings, and concern that that the Australian Standard for Marinas was being applied in an ocean access situation that was not relevant to a marina.

It was stressed by DSE that they had shown the maximum, or ‘worst case scenario’ length of breakwater in the H2 option, and that the final could be shorter and lower. Unfortunately, no examples of what it could look like in reduced form were available for participants to view.

Submission responses will be collated by Department of Transport to inform East Gippsland Shire Council of community preferences (3b, H2, or other). According to local member Tim Bull, the Government is committed to progressing either option H2 or 3b, both of which contain breakwaters.


Hyder Proposal and Analysis

Please see our new web pages on the Hyder Proposal, and our Analysis of Hyder.

The Department of Transport page on the Hyder proposals may be accessed here.